Halloween Mystery Activity: The Candy Thief

The Halloween Mystery Activity: The Candy Thief is the first clue by clue I wrote with a holiday theme, namely Halloween. It’s also the first one  targeted to younger learners. While trick or treating, a boy is knocked over and his candy stolen. His three friends were wearing costumes so they didn’t see much. But, one of them is lying about what they know.  Can your students find the lie and figure out which one was an accomplice to the robbery?

While the mystery may be aimed at younger learners, the benefits of a clue by clue are clear. As with all clue by clue mysteries, students are given the situation to analyze. They are then given the clue cards, one at a time. In pairs or small groups, students analyze each clue to try to decide if it’s relevant or irrelevant. They also analyze it to figure out how it helps solve the mystery. It’s a great way for students to practice critical thinking skills. Solving a mystery means evaluating evidence, synthesizing information from different clues, and telling truth from lie and fact from opinion. (Check out my post on Why short mysteries make awesome critical thinking activities for more and a list of all my clue by clue activities).


Halloween Mystery Activity The Candy Thief Preview
The Teacher Sheet
Halloween Mystery Activity The Candy Thief Preview
The Student Sheet

Download The Candy Thief Halloween Mystery Activity

So, head over to my Teachers Pay Teachers Store to purchase my Halloween Mystery Activity The Candy Thief  Mystery Activity!

Or check out the other Clue by Clue Mystery Activities. Check out a list of my other Halloween activities and lesson plans here.

You can also visit my ever-growing section of mystery activities and lesson plans for other classroom resources, including a graphic organizer and story cards to help students write their own mysteries.

Liked this post? Check out some of my books on

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.